A 15 year old that knows Pizza. 100+ slices rated. No free pizza. No perfect 10s – nobody's perfect. Critiquing pizza since 2018.
Rating- 7.9
I got a sicilian, my Dad got a plain slice. My Dad’s slice had alotta flop, and he doesn’t like flop but he said his was really good, he would have given it over an 8 but I didn’t because I’m a tougher critic. Most people think Pizza is Pizza, but not me. We also got pepperoni twists which i did not eat but my Dad said were good. My Dad used to live around here and said its good. I would recommend this pizza.
Rating – 8.7
Tonight, I got a silician, my Dad got a plain slice. This pizza is pretty good. When you walk in to get the pizza, the waiting area is pretty small and it was pretty crowded, but it’s not a bad thing. When my Dad pulled in the parking lot I thought we were going to get pizza in Stop and Stop. My Dad thinks this is really good pizza. We found out about this place in the Westchester Magazine pizza issue. This place also had a restaurant. I recommend this Pizza.
Rating – 9.0
I’m reviewing this again, because this time I got a marinara slice ( no cheese).it was very good, it was crispy, not a lot of flop. Its a pretty big slice. We ate our pizza there. Garlic knots were good. My dad thought they were the best. I think Broadways are better. This pizza is good.
Rating – 7.2
This slice was just OK. The cheese wasn’t very good, and the texture was weird. It was just OK. The garlic knots were big and pretty good.
Rating – 8.9
This is a high rating for Supermarket pizza. My mommy loves this place. My mommy gives the Supermarket a 10. I took off the cheese, but it was good looking cheese. Sometimes I take off the cheese. There wasn’t too much or too little. I would like to have it again and I recommend it. It’s coming to Westchester soon June 7th.
Rating – 8.2
It’s good. Not too floppy. I like sauce and the bread. My friends Maggie, Billy, Caitlin, Jake, Maya and Emmy all really liked it. Alex also liked it. He said he liked everything about it. Billy said the sauce and cheese are pretty good. Maggie and Caitlin had second slices they thought they were so good. Caitlin, Maggie and Maya said they think all pizza tastes the same. I do not. I usually think that NY pizza is the best and that’s not just because I’m from NY. I was also pretty hungry.
Rating – 7.2
I went got pizza from this place with my cousin, Caileigh. This is where “she” gets pizza from. We had to wait 20 minutes to get the pizza. We also got garlic knots. The garlic knots were better than the pizza. The pizza had wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy too much cheese. I don’t like tht much cheese. But the garlic knots were so good. We took the pizza back to Caileigh’s house and her brother ,Emmet had no pants on. I don’t think he had pizza. Caileigh likes the pizza, she would give it a 10 out of 10, but I am a harder critic.
Rating – 8.0
First of all, this place has slices that are 2 feet long. its one of the biggest slices in the world. They call it the Super Slice. The slice is pretty thick. Not alot of sauce. I prefer a lotta sauce. We got the pizza there and took it home. It was a 10 minute wait. They said it would be a 15 minute wait, but it was 10. Slice is pretty good, but not as good as some other pizza that I’ve had. It was pretty cool to see a big slice of pizza, it was half the size of me. I’m glad we tried it, but not the best pizza i’ve ever had. https://www.pizzabarnyonkers.com/
Rating – 8.3
This was a tomato pie. We had this when we went to Hershey, PA with some of our friends. And by some, I mean 40 people. There were a bunch of squares without cheese. It wasn’t like regular pizza. It had no cheese, just sauce and bread. It was kinda like a sicilian slice, but not as thick. My friend , Owen’s, Uncle brought it for everyone we went to Hershey with. We stayed in a hotel and we all ate it in the lobby. We stayed up after midnight. Even though the pizza is from Philly, we like it even though we don’t like Philly sports teams. The sauce was good but a little weird, it was very sweet. It wasn’t like anything I’ve every had before. i would recommend this pizza if you are in or near Philly.
Rating – 9
I give this pizza a 9. The crust is very crispy, so it is not floppy. I usually like a thin, floppy pizza, but suprisingly, this is good. The sauce is really good too. My mom gets it with no cheese and it’s good that way too. The garlic knots are good too. I w0uld recommend this place.
